When I think of people that would be in line to criticize MLB on Fox analyst Tim McCarver, plenty of individuals immediately come to mind (including the entire staff of this site). But one name I never would have pinned was legendary CBC hockey commentator Don Cherry. Cherry took issue with McCarver on his Twitter page (yes, Don Cherry tweets too!) because he jinxed Ryan Vogelsong's no-hitter on Sunday night in Game 6 of the NLCS.
Tim McCarver, one of my favourite announcers, has lost his feel for baseball and now is officially a tv announcer. San Fransisco pitcher ..— Don Cherry (@CoachsCornerCBC) October 22, 2012
Vogelsond is sailing along last night in the 5th inning with a no hitter. Everybody knows you should never, ever mention it. All of a sudden— Don Cherry (@CoachsCornerCBC) October 22, 2012
McCarver mentions the no hitter and well you know what happens next.Is he nuts? Sure enough next hitter belts a double then the next guy— Don Cherry (@CoachsCornerCBC) October 22, 2012
drives in the run.Tim has lost his feel for baseball.Either he's above that silly stuff or he listened to an egg head tv guy who told— Don Cherry (@CoachsCornerCBC) October 22, 2012
him to mention it to create excitement for the fans. He sold his soul.And I was pissed!— Don Cherry (@CoachsCornerCBC) October 22, 2012
This is crazy. Cherry's main issue with McCarver isn't his rambling style, random sayings, and loss of touch with the game of baseball, but him jinxing a no hitter in progress? Saying McCarver "sold his soul" to some unknown power of darkness? It's true, maybe Cherry just felt bored with no NHL topics to rant about.
The concept of an announcer jinxing a no hitter and having some concrete role in the outcome of a baseball game is a backwards superstition. Come to think of it, given Cherry's old school mentality maybe it makes sense why he would take issue with it. But, McCarver did the right thing in actually telling viewers what was actually happening.
Now if only Tim McCarver had a comeback about Don Cherry's wardrobe. Then we'd really take a trip into bizarro world.
Cherry is an old frustrated bigot.One of the stupidest guy on TV .He is the O'Reilly of sports.Hes nut(sorry for the name calling),but him and his puppet beside him...cant stand them.
"Either he's above that silly stuff or he listened to an egg head tv guy who told"
So Cherry thinks the notion of a no-hitter jinx is silly, yet he condemns McCarver for jinxing it? What a bunch of nonsense.