Wednesday night Jim Boeheim made waves when he called ESPN college basketball reporter Andy Katz an "idiot" and "disloyal" at a postgame press conference. While there were numerous theories as to why Boeheim would explode at Katz in such a way, initial reports were that Boeheim may have been upset over Katz's reporting that night on James Southerland, an Orange player declared academically ineligible.
Turns out that's not the case. After initially providing a no comment about the matter, Boeheim recounted the genesis of his feud with Katz via Syracuse.com - an interview in November 2011 where Katz pushed Boeheim about the Bernie Fine case:
“It’s really simple,” he explained. “I went to New York last year to play in the (NIT Pre-Season Tip-Off) Tournament in November and he (Katz) asked if he could interview me about the tournament. And I said, ‘Yeah, but I can’t talk about the (Bernie Fine) investigation.’
“We got in the room and he put me on camera — there were several witnesses there — and he asked me what I’d told him I couldn’t answer. I kept telling him, ‘I can’t answer that.’ And he asked me, like, 10 times on camera. He never took the camera off me.
“Two or three people in the room were so disgusted they walked out of the room. The producer came over and apologized afterward. And I told Katz right then and there, ‘Don’t talk to me. Do not try to talk to me again.’
“That’s what this is about. It’s about one thing: An interview that was supposed to be about a tournament we were playing in, and not about the (Bernie Fine) case. And he kept asking me about the case over and over and over again. He kept the camera on me, trying to get me to react ... and I just didn’t.”
Katz also responded about Boeheim's comments to Syracuse.com, saying Boeheim indeed hasn't talked to him since 2011 and the Bernie Fine controversy:
But Katz did say that he hasn't spoken to Boeheim since the height of the Bernie Fine scandal last season when Katz covered Syracuse's game against Florida at the Carrier Dome on Dec. 2. It was after that game that Boeheim offered an apology for his comments regarding Fine's accusers.
"I've not seen Jim since that Florida game,'' Katz said. "I've made multiple attempts to get him on various shows. I called him when Notre Dame announced they were leaving the Big East because he's Mr. Big East and he hung up on me.
"He said 'Andy, you know I'm not talking to you' and hung up.''
So Jim Boeheim has held this grudge against Andy Katz for over a year because of an interview that went out of bounds? You can question ESPN's role in the Bernie Fine case as we have previously, but at the time isn't it Katz's responsibility to try and get Boeheim to comment on the story? Would Katz be doing his job if he agreed to let Boeheim get away with a free pass when the Syracuse head coach so publicly inserted himself into the story? Or would you rather have Katz agree to those interview conditions at the height of a huge scandal and say, "Yes sir, Mr. Boeheim, whatever you say, let's dig into that 2-3 matchup zone!"
Did Katz cross the line and become belligerent by asking dozens of questions? Only a handful of individuals know and right now we only have Boeheim's side of the story as to what exactly happened during that interview.
But this doesn't change the fact that Jim Boeheim crossed a line Wednesday night with another press conference bullying act. Boeheim did admit that he shouldn't have called Katz an "idiot" saying "sometimes that happens after games" but let's not pretend like he's actually sorry about that given his past history. It won't be long before Boeheim is trying to lord his power and authority over another media member because of something he doesn't like. His story also makes his "disloyal" comment all the more puzzling. Again, Andy Katz's loyalty does not lie with Jim Boeheim. For Boeheim to publicly try to embarrass Katz because of a year long grudge and Katz doing his job just seems petty and vindictive.
UPDATE: In an additional statement released via ESPN PR, Katz disputes Boeheim's story saying there was never an agreement in place between the pair with regards to questions about Bernie Fine:
“Nothing of the sort took place. There was never any agreement not to ask Fine-related questions. In fact, that was ESPN’s first chance to speak with Coach Boeheim after the Fine news broke so of course we would ask him about it. He had just come from a press conference where he addressed it as well. Separately, later in that tournament, he agreed to talk to me on camera for a post-game interview.”
Katz is retarded. I don't blame Jim.....its childish on espn's part to say one thing and then do another after they were told they cannot ask questions about the case
@awfulannouncing Andy Katz works for @ESPN. Enough said. Worst news reporting organization in media, except for ABC, CBS, NBC, MSNBC, FOX.
@awfulannouncing how hard is this to understand ? JB told the idiot what he WASN'T going to talk about but idiot insists on asking. #idiot
@awfulannouncing Katz story keeps changing. Release the tape and it will be obvi who is being straight. #Syracuse
Keep trying to spin it any way you want to but good luck trying to make Boeheim as the bad guy and Katz as the victim. Boeheim wasn’t perfect but his actions are 100% understandable and Katz is a douche.
Uhh, Andy Katz is an idiot. Calhoun during his sideline interview last night mentioned at least 3 times that he wanted to enjoy the last 10 minutes of the game. Katz couldn't pick up on it and kept asking ?s
He said I agree to be interviewed but dont ask me about this subject. If Katz thought it was unfair to have that category out of bounds, he should have said I wont do the interview if I cant ask these questions. They had a handshake agreement that certain questions wouldnt be asked and Katz went back on it. Thats unprofessional plain and simple.
@awfulannouncing ESPN is responsible, Can every announcer from ESPN be added as an awful announcer. They all suck!
Some may find Jim Boeheim to be in the right in this situation; but Andy Katz was simply using a journalistic technique that made Mike Wallace a legend. Mr. Boeheim can hold whatever grudges he wishes, but ESPN ought to support Mr. Katz completely.
Don't see how anyone can fault Boeheim for taking this stance. Impolitely executed, maybe, but put yourself in his shoes, sports media.