In preparation for its August launch, the announcements are coming fast and furious for Fox Sports 1. Today came the unveiling of the cast that will join Crowd Goes Wild, the sports potpourri show hosted by Regis Philbin.
Apparently that wasn't a gag the first time it was announced.
And no, I'm not putting that dumb exclamation mark in the title.
Yes, Reege will be there from Day 1 and he'll be joined by a panel that can be best described as... completely and totally random. Like, almost as if Fox Sports put 10,000 people into one of those spinning lottery machines and it spit out the names you'll see below. Fox is trying to give it the hard sell (as you'll see below) by promoting the ecclectic personalities that will appear. One can't force eclecticism and irreverency, though. When you do that, you end up with UNITE. May it rest in peace.
Alas, FS1 will be giving this UNCONVENTIONAL and UNPREDICTABLE show a try with Reege, a Wall Street Journal columnist (Jason Gay), a former tennis player turned comedian (Michael Kosta), a former NFL player (Trevor Pryce), a former Sky Sports News host (Georgie Thompson), and an online host (Katie Nolan). If you're wondering how it's all going to mesh together - don't worry, you're not alone. Here's the announcement from Fox:
Unpredictable, unconventional and irreverent are three adjectives that describe CROWD GOES W!LD, FOX Sports 1’s new, original sports discussion and analysis program, and all most-definitely describe five eclectic personalities named today to join renown host Regis Philbin when the show premieres on Monday, Aug. 19.
Veteran Wall Street Journal sports columnist Jason Gay; professional tennis player turned comedian Michael Kosta; two-time Super Bowl Champion and four-time Pro Bowl defensive end Trevor Pryce; and Sky Sports host and news anchor Georgie Thompson, along with Guyism.com personality and YouTube sensation Katie Nolan serving as social media correspondent, team with Regis to come at the day’s sports news and issues with conversation more lively, more entertaining and less argumentative than current offerings.
“There are sports news shows, debate shows and shows that present a single point-of-view, but CROWD GOES W!LD is aiming for a fresh approach,” said Executive Producer Michael Davies. “CROWD GOES W!LD is going to live in the moment, presenting multiple points of view, with the conversation often influenced by the audience through social interaction. Regis, Jason, Michael, Trevor, Georgie and Katie will embrace the freedom and spontaneity this free-flowing, less staid, format offers and I have no doubt fans will too.”
In addition to featuring conversation directed by its panelists’ contrasting viewpoints and social interaction with viewers, the alternative CROWD GOES W!LD (@CGW) welcomes in-studio guests from sports and entertainment, and incorporates every asset FOX Sports offers, ranging from live satellite interviews with on-air personalities to cast members serving as correspondents at major events.
See, here's the thing I'm having trouble with... how do you promote something as "fresh" and "unpredictable" and wonky and zany when you employ as your host an 81 year old man who has been in the TV biz since the Johnson administration?
I hate to pre-judge anything too harshly, but I'm willing to predict that out of any show in the FS1 lineup this will have a major overhaul within months, if not weeks. I can't imagine Regis Philbin having an appeal at all with FS1's fanbase and instead of letting something grow organically, this has "painfully forced" written all over it. And, it's going up against the ESPN staples of ATH and PTI at 5 PM ET.
Although some of the individual pieces of this puzzle may be appealing and have a future at the network, I'm skeptical about the success of Crowd Goes Wild (especially with that crazy exclamation mark in the title). Good puzzle pieces are nice, but you have to make sure those pieces eventually fit together to complete an actual puzzle. Otherwise they're just a bunch of useless extra puzzle pieces. And what good are those for?
I wished they'd take an approach like NBC did with their show, "NBC Sports Talk". "NBC Sports Talk" focused solely on sports topics and covered the x's and o's of a story without getting into all of the sensationalistic hype that ESPN (and now seemingly FS1) do. Of course, they cancelled that and put Michelle Beadle's pop-culture show "The Crossover" in it's place, so NBC's executives are not patron saints. However, I do want FS1 to give a legitimate newsy-esque sports talk show a try as I'm tired of all of the pop-culture spin type shows.
Michael Kosta gets a pass from me because he's a graduate of the University of Illinois and he's actually pretty funny. And he appears to know sports judging from some of his tweets. Calling him a former professional tennis player might be a little bit of a stretch, but again, he's orange and blue so he gets the benefit of my doubt. As for the rest of it, who the hell knows. It'll depend on how much "Domer" talk you can stomach from Reege. Kosta will have to be on alert to thwart some of that. The prediction of a quick overhaul would be a good bet in Vegas.
This show line-up reminds me of a college football program trying to form an identity by throwing whatever they can think of together and seeing if it works. Sometimes it works, but often it does not. While ATH has lost it's sizzle for my tastes, I'm not sure this show has enough to hit the ground running to make a serious run at ESPN's core evening programming. But, we'll see.
I don't think it's going to work, it seems like they just put names in a hat and these are the names they came up with.
I love Regis but the audience FS1 is trying to get, will not even know who he is for the most part.
I remember ABC tried something similar a couple of years ago, but they didn't like the pilot.
Don't think ATH and PTI have anything to worry about.
Mike Kosta was an unfunny douche in high school, so it amuses me that he's still an unfunny douche and a starving comedian.
There's a successful Fox Sports show built around Regis somewhere, I'm sure, but I don't think this is it.
I'd be happier with just Reege and one guest host per week, a la Mike Douglas. But this format makes me think that Reege will only be on full time until about November 1, and then you'll start seeing him taking weeks off left and right until he's only on two or three times a month via satellite.
If these are the people they Came up with. I would hate to see who they rejected. This show won't last long.