Like most baseball fans and writers in America, I’ve been captivated by the tale of the 2013 Pittsburgh Pirates. A smaller market team overcoming two decades of misfortune and misery to not only break a 20-year streak of sub-.500 futility but make the postseason for the first time since 1992, nearly winning a division title. The Pittsburgh Pirates would be hosting the first postseason game ever at PNC Park, its gem of a ballpark which opened in 2001. But unless you were one of the 41,000+ fans and media at PNC Park on Tuesday night, you could not watch the adoring fans welcome home their conquering heroes, exploding with emotion and gratitude.
TBS, one of MLB’s three broadcast partners for the postseason, did not show the traditional pre-game player introductions, National Anthem or ceremonial first pitch before Pittsburgh’s 6-2 win over the Cincinnati Reds. Let that wash over you again: there was no television coverage of what should have been -- and was -- some of the most compelling drama of the evening.
This was the best story in baseball and I, along with most interested observers, could not wait to see how the Pirates and their fans celebrated the return of postseason baseball. As 8 o’clock on the east coast approached, I kept waiting for TBS to leave the pre-game studio show with Keith Olbermann, Mark DeRosa, Pedro Martinez and Dirk Hayhurst to bring us the on-field player introductions, National Anthem and ceremonial first pitch. It never happened.
Instead of showing the raw, emotional rejoicing that was taking place at PNC, Olbermann and company talked about what a great event this would be and how the emotions would be high. I was stunned. TBS knew that this was happening because its producers cut in for brief glimpses of MVP favorite Andrew McCutchen and NL home run champion Pedro Alvarez being introduced to thunderous applause. But after a few seconds, the broadcast returned to the studio where the talking heads engaged in some nonsensical conversation about whether or not Olbermann had actually attended Cornell University.
Meanwhile, I started seeing tweets from fans and media members at the ballpark talking about the spectacular atmosphere at the park and how great the player introductions were, including “MVP” chants for McCutchen.
This game hasn’t started, and we’ve already had the greatest 10 minutes in PNC Park history. #Pirates— Dejan Kovacevic (@Dejan_Kovacevic) October 2, 2013
And some video from Dejan Kovacevic of the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review. Yeah this would have been terrible television. Nobody wants to see this.
Here’s just a sample of the atmosphere courtesy of Matt Maisel of WJAC. Pretty compelling stuff, yes?
The official Pirates Twitter account posted a cool Vine of the player introductions. Chill-inducing.
Then I learned that the National Anthem had been performed by Andrew McCutchen’s mother, Petrina, to a thunderous ovation.
Andrew McCutchen's mom just sang the National anthem, the whole crowd joined in, then she hugged her son and sent him off to play.— Kristie Ackert (@AckertNYDN) October 2, 2013
That’s right, the presumptive NL MVP’s mother performed the National Anthem and this incredible moment was not televised nationally. Seriously?
Here’s a clip of the some of the anthem performance, courtesy of Matt Maisel of WJAC again:
Yeah, I think America would have liked to have seen this. Kovacevic then tweeted that former Pirate great and fan favorite Doug Drabek threw a strike for the ceremonial first pitch.
I was irate and took to Twitter (of course) to vent my frustration.
No live player intros, no live National Anthem. It's only the first postseason game at PNC Park. No big deal.— Amanda Rykoff (@amandarykoff) October 1, 2013
It turns out I was not alone in my anger and frustration with TBS’s failure to show the pre-game events. The tweets were flying fast and furious.
Just as I say that, TBS eschews the pregame intros. 21 years without playoffs and we can't hear Buccos fans laud their boys. Brutal!— Gabe Lacques (@GabeLacques) October 1, 2013
Twitter tells me the anthem was awesome, the first pitch was awesome and the player intros were awesome. TBS showed me a studio show. Ugh.— Ryan Fagan (@ryanfagan) October 2, 2013
Wait ... Andrew McCutchen's mom sings the national anthem and they don't show it?— David Schoenfield (@dschoenfield) October 2, 2013
We need more restraint in our public speech, so I'm going to be responsible and merely say everyone at TBS should be horsewhipped.— Jason Fry (@jasoncfry) October 2, 2013
No player intros or anthem on TBS? Instead we get Keith Olbermann showing a picture of his degree from Cornell. Come on... #Pirates— Josh Rowntree (@JRown32) October 2, 2013
Yes TBS, I would rather watch a bunch of guys talk about the pre-game atmosphere at PNC than actually, you know, watch it.— Josh H. (@PittCabe) October 2, 2013
The outrage wasn’t directed at Olbermann personally but the studio host did tweet about it in response to some criticism, deflecting presumably to the director.
Sure. Because a host makes those decisions. RT @Heeb265 thanks for skipping the pirates intros an awesome crowd scene.— Keith Olbermann (@KeithOlbermann) October 2, 2013
As the game progressed, the broadcast did a decent job of acknowledging the crowd and giving a sense of the incredible atmosphere at the ballpark. But TBS didn’t seem to understand that this Wild Card game was much more than a game. Failing to show the pre-game events and sharing the moment with the audience was simply unacceptable. Maybe they can get it right when the Pirates host Game Three of the NLDS against the division rival St. Louis Cardinals on Sunday, October 6.
UPDATE: MLB released official footage of the anthem performed by Petrina McCutchen that was not broadcast last night, including the emotional embrace between mother and son at the end. Yeah, that isn't compelling television.
TBS is a straight-up abortion: terrible announcing, terrible studio show, terrible production. MLB should be ashamed they are partners with such a low rent network.
@Buctober_Bound great read til i read it mentioned Keith Olbermann, then i threw up in my mouth
What is MLB thinking having a non-sports channel TBS as the broadcast station for this game? The game, the venue, the players their stories and struggles was the story...not idiot Keith Oberman- and his talking head fools in the studio. Now that I Know Oberman is part of TBS...they've lost a viewer. The announcers for the game were equally as dull and you couldn't even hear them speaking. Will watch next game and listen to radio broadcasts with ROOT sports !!! Go Buccos...we love you!
It's a conspiracy I tell ya. And Ted Turner's behind it. TBS? Atlanta Braves? Yep. Well the ghost of Sid Bream's slide is officially dead, Ted. So suck on those lemons!
@amandarykoff Great work.
@amandarykoff great article. I knew it was a different kind of night when the rotunda was full of chanting fans a full hour before the start
@amandarykoff great stuff
TBS Stands for "The Broadcast Sucks" and they proved it. Maybe they should just stick tor showing reruns of Family Guy or something like that. They have proven they can't handle an important event at all. #LetsGoPirates #LetsGoMarauders
@amandarykoff So they pulled an every-year FOX Canadian National Anthem non-show, but even 100 times worse. Unbelievable.
But yet if it was the Yankees or Red Sox..... Im disappointed too, just another reason why the NFL is #1 cause they for sure wld not have made this mistake
@amandarykoff Thanks! Nice piece. Studio show was solid, but TBS - total lack of anticipation PNC scene would be A Thing, failed to adjust.
TBS coverage is horrible to begin with, starting with that damn pitch tracker that takes up half the screen.
Would have been far more compelling to have had a constant feed on Marty as Dusty was ruining yet another season. This team needs a Larry Bowa-type leader both on the field and off. 2-7 in the playoffs.
@amandarykoff enjoyed this post quite a bit. Seriously, no one cares about the talking heads. The ceremonies are much better TV
Thank you very much @amandarykoff for addressing this. Completely unacceptable. What Olbermann needs to know is people aren't as upset at him directly about this as they are just sick of his shtick that got old 20 years ago.
@amandarykoff As a baseball fan, I'm glad to see Pirates fans finally get that feeling again. There's nothing better.
@amandarykoff Regardless, it's a shame they didn't show that. I was at the Tigers' first home playoff game in 06 and it was incredible.
@amandarykoff Very interesting (I missed the pre game). Did national media do the same when Detroit made it in 06? It was a smiler situation
@robneyer completely agree with this
@robneyer Thanks, Rob. Much appreciated. I am still irate over the decision to skip the pre-game festivities.
@craigcalcaterra You left out Ron Darling. Did not add a thing.
@robneyer I want to know why a one-game playoff doesn't merit network TV coverage. No cable = no game. Even with MLB.tv. That sucks.
@craigcalcaterra Part of what was wrong is that there was a one-game playoff not on network TV. Then people say baseball gets bad ratings.
This TBS contract has been an utter catastrophe for MLB. Why on earth did they re-up til 2021? By that time, 7 people will be watching nationally televised games.
Keith Olbermann stunk when he was with msnbc(MSLSD) that's why he got fired.
Someone please get him out of TV and especially sports.
@hangingsliders Thanks Wendy. Appreciate it.
@GabeLacques Thanks. Not knocking the studio show but yes, failure to shift to the ballpark for pre-game emotion was a huge swing and miss.
@amandarykoff Is the AA stuff a "permanent" thing or a one-off or something else? Congrats, by the way.
@DangerousMabry I watched the game on mlb.tv, don't know why you couldn't. Cost me $5 for the LDS and LCS plus the two WC games.
@amandarykoff When branding and initiatives trump, you know, coverage! Sigh. As you note, hopefully they'll adjust.
@amandarykoff Ah. For someone from Cincy, it was the only part of the game I wish I could have seen (or unsee).